Each one is the right answer for some stores. I run Sage, so read this knowing that. I've tried to say plainly when you shouldn't pick it.
| Cost | Who decides what to fix | Who does it | Best for | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| App | Free, or about $35 to $65 a month | You | The app, in bulk, on your settings | Small stores with time to learn SEO |
| Freelancer | Most often $75 to $100 an hour | Them, for that job | Them | One-off jobs: a migration, a fix, an audit |
| Agency | From $2,500 a month at WebFX, one-year commitment | Them | Them | Bigger budgets that need links and PR too |
| Sage | $50, then $150 a month | Sage, from your data, every week | Sage, after you approve | Stores with some Google traffic that want the work done weekly |
Sources, checked 13 November 2026: Booster and Avada, the two most-reviewed Shopify SEO apps, from their listings; WebFX's published ecommerce SEO pricing; freelancer rates from Ahrefs' survey of 439 SEO providers (August 2024).
Booster and Avada, the two most-reviewed SEO apps on the Shopify App Store, are good at the bulk jobs: filling in alt text, compressing images, adding product markup, writing titles from a template. They're cheap and they're fast.
What they don't do is decide. An app will happily rewrite 400 meta descriptions when the thing actually costing you sales is a collection page that ranks ninth for your best search. Working out which change matters is still your job.
Pick an app if your budget is tight, your catalogue is small, and you'd enjoy learning Search Console.
Freelance SEO most often costs $75 to $100 an hour, according to Ahrefs' survey of SEO providers. A good Shopify freelancer is the best value there is for a defined job. Moving from another platform, fixing a theme that hides products from Google, a one-time audit with a clear list of fixes.
Quality varies more than with any other option, and ongoing work tends to stop when their calendar fills up.
Pick a freelancer if you can describe the job in one sentence and it has an end. Ask for before-and-after examples from Shopify stores, not general websites.
An agency can do what no tool can: earn links from other sites, run PR, produce content at volume, and handle a large catalogue with a team. If you need off-site work, that's the honest answer.
It costs a lot more, usually with a minimum term. WebFX, one of the largest, starts ecommerce SEO at $2,500 a month on a one-year commitment. Check who actually works on your account, and how often you'll see what changed.
Pick an agency if you have a few thousand dollars a month for a year and need links or PR as well as on-site work.
Sage sits between an app and an agency. Every week it reads your Search Console data, crawls your store, checks your competitors and picks the one change that matters most. It writes the change in your brand's voice and queues it. You approve it in about 15 minutes a week, and then it goes live.
Pick Sage if you run a Shopify D2C store that already gets some impressions in Search Console, and you want someone to choose and do the work without paying agency rates.
Don't pick Sage if:
The proof so far is one store, my own: Kunvarani's work log.
For a small store with time to spare, often yes. Apps fill in titles, alt text and markup in bulk. They don't decide what matters most for your store, so that part stays with you.
When you need work beyond your own site, like links, PR and large content programs, and have a budget of a few thousand dollars a month for a year.
For a defined, one-off job: a migration, a theme fix, a one-time audit. Ask for before-and-after examples from Shopify stores.
Shopify D2C stores that already get some impressions in Search Console and want the weekly work chosen and done for them, with a person signing off every change.
Written by Khushi Dassani, founder of Sage SEOMatic. I built Sage to run SEO for my own Shopify brand first.
The free audit shows what's actually holding your store back. Then you can pick any of the four. No Google login, no sales call.
Get my free audit →